CRUFTS 2007 - DEERHOUND CRITIQUE

Very many thanks to all the exhibitors who brought their hounds for me to go over. It is a great honour to judge such a prestigious show and Mick had got very tired of me shopping and changing outfits. I was very relieved when it was over but I was happy with my decisions.

I found in my CC dog winner an honest hound with no exaggerations – presented in the best condition and obviously not fazed by anything.

I found in my BOB a lovely typical bitch with a gentle expression, lots of curves with the head I love. There were a few placing that would have been different if the dogs were in better condition and had less fat on them and a few more if the owners had got them to move better. Very many thanks to my stewards who were a pleasure to work with, it made my job easier.

I am writing critiques 1 – 3 and placings to 5 . I know the Dog papers edit from time to time and I want to expand the judgements to explain why I did what I did.

Many thanks to Jeff and Barbara Poole who supplied pictures of the winning hounds, the others were taken by Mick. Please contact Jeff and Barbara barb.jeff@virgin.net if you wish to have a copy.

CLASS 1936 - NO ENTRIES
CLASS 1937 SPECIAL PUPPY DOG - 5 ENTERED 3 PRESENT

1ST GREYFRIARS GILLE OF BEARDSWOOD BP


A big puppy dog , very nice straight front and good depth for his age, he moved out well showing all the curves nice strong bone and substance, well muscled and in pristine condition. For me a tad strong in the head but there was much to like about this dog pup, he won Best Puppy on his movement.

2ND READWALD FLINT


What a nice dog puppy, all the right curves and another one to watch. Good bone and substance; lovely dark coat, nice head ears and a dark eye, his front is a tad out at the moment but I am pretty sure this will tighten as he gets older. I preferred his head to the first but he lost it to better moving dog.

no image sorry

3RD LAIRD OF LISNABANREE AT ANMIALCHU


A very big strong male with plenty of size bone and substance, this lad was not co-operating with his owner at all and so I was unable to assess his movement, owner and dog need a bit of practice and then it could be a different picture.

no image sorry
CLASS 1938 SPECIAL JUNIOR DOG - 7 ENTERED - ALL PRESENT

1ST CANERIKIE CROCODILE COOLER


What a lovely typical hound, nice shapely body with good length, excellent head, ears and expression, deep enough in body for his age with a lovely topline and strong quarters. Excellent length from hip to hock moved out with great drive jeeping his shape and covering the ground well. Presented and shown in excellent order, he pushed hard for the CC. This hound is very young and in the hands of a novice but I am sure they are a winning combination and have places to go.

2nd LORD SEAFIELD OF HARTVALLEY


A big dog with bone and substance, ears are a big heavy but a good straight front, strong bone and nice feet, powerful neck and lovely deep body but not quite the angles fore and aft of the winner. Overall a honest hound who moved around the ring with presence and drive.

3rd KILLOETER LUSS


This dog was not a happy bunny, he was not relaxed and on another day, another show, he could be placed higher. Lovely strong bone, nice deep body, good low hocks and a nice topline but he did not move out well.

4th WOLFSCASTLE FINLAY

5th L YART YES MINISTER

 
CLASS 1939 YEARLING DOG 7 ENTIRES 1 ABSENT

1ST PACKWAY DENALI AT HARTVALLEY


Another nice big hound who had good strong neck, nice deep body, adequate for his age, a good straight front with a nicebend in the pastern. ½ brother to the winner of the last class and a lot of the same applies to him, still very rangy and not as mature but showing lots of promise, he moved covering the ground well.

2ND GLEWLWYD DIONYSUS


This is another nice shapely hound with a good coat, not quite the range of 1. Rather heavy in the head but good bone and substance. A slight weakness in the pastern and feet but very deep in the chest with good angulation behind, moved ok.

3RD CRAFFITSH O'COCKAIGNE


This was a huge dog that was far too big for me, massive bone and substance, nice straight front, lovely harsh coat, long in the back and very dark coat hard coat. He moved well covering the ground.

4TH COTHERSTONE THE MAGICIAN BY BREESFALT  
5TH PACKWAY ACONCAGAGUA  
CLASS 1940 POST GRADUATE DOG 11 ENTIRES 4 ABSENT

1ST ROSSLYN NEILL


This is a big dog that has good body, very strong neck and a nice head and expression. Just a little short in upper arm but fabulous length and he kept his topline standing and on the move. Good angulation and length from hip to hock His movement could be a little tighter a very nice type.

2ND DORRATOR NATHANIEL AT AONACHDUBH


A similar dog to the winner, slightly upright in shoulder, good depth bone and substance a nice type but not as positive on the move, presented and handled well.

3RD CLAONAIGLEN ORCHY


A slightly smaller dog with a good body, nice head and ears, good angles both fore and aft but tends to flatten in topline standing and on the move. Moved ok

4TH CLAONAIGLEN NEVIS  
5TH DEMERLAY DORIAN GREY AT CELTICMOON  
CLASS 1941 LIMIT DPG - 9 ENTRIES 2 ABSENT

1ST KILLOETER GRILSE

This is a very honest hound that looks as if he can do the job he was bred for. He was presented and shown to perfection, the owner obviously working as one with him. He has good bone and substance, a nice deep chest with plenty of heart room, a good topline and adequate angulation behind presenting a balanced hound who has no exaggerations.
I was very pleased to award him his 1st CC


2ND WOLFSCASTLE WOOD MELICK


Another dog very similar to 1 but today he could not do enough, lacked drive and enthusiam on the move. Built on the same lines this is another dog that looks like he could do the job. Pushed hard for the Reserve CC but lost that today on movement.

I was told later he had been in the ring since 8am with his junior handler where he won the YJH 6-11 class, I feel this may have cost him his place in the breeed ring but well done.

 

3RD GENTOM ORLANDO AT TALGAVAR


I thought when this dog came into the ring he was my winner, he has good strong neck falling into good shoulders excellent length of body and nice angles front and rear but today I found him reluctant to move and stride out.

4th KENMILLITRI JOCK  
5th HILLM ORTON ECLIPSE  
CLASS 1942 OPEN DOG - 7 ENTIRES 3 ABSENT

1ST CH.HYNDSIGHT WIND OF CHANGE


This is a big winning hound with much to like about him. He won his place on overall conformation , good bone substance and overal quality but today he did not move out well and is a tad overweight which may explain his lack of enthusiasm for the show ring today.

2ND WICKWAR WORCESTER OF PEOPLETON


A smaller hound who standing looks short in the neck but as our old standard said this can be an illusion caused by a mane, something you rarely see these days as it is stripped out. He has such a mane and is not short in neck, he quite balanced and keeps his topline on the move.

3RD BEARDSWOOD MARMION


A much bigger dog with good bone and size, a nice head and expression, deep in chest but flattens his topline on the move and is a tad upright on his shoulder which makes him move with his head rather high.

4th anmailchu beinn buachaille  
CLASS 1943 GOOD CITIZEN DOG SCHEME 1N ENTRY

1ST NOBYS FERGUS


This is a big strong dog who stood alone in this special class. Nice to see him and he has obviously gained a lot of merit from the Good Citizen scheme. Well done.

CLASS 1944 VETERAN BITCH 1 ENTRY

1ST INT/LUX CH.R'IHAFIA OF MUMA


Very big French bitch that today carried far too much weight and her coat needed attention. Very shapely with a good lay of shoulder and lots of depth and strength in the body with exactly the right topline. She was very reluctant to move out with any enthusiasm. .

CLASS 1945 SPECIAL PUPPY B ITCH 5 ENTRIES

1ST GREYFLAX MILLY MOLLY MANDY


Nice big strong puppy bitch with a lot to like about her, shown to perfection and has all the right curves. Very slightly short in upper arm but she moves out very well but lost out to the dog puppy in the puppy challenge on overall movement.

2ND WICKWAR WALNUT WHIP


Nice type, slightly smaller than one and three but a lovely head and ears, good forechest And body, nice deep chest and well laid shoulders, a promising puppy.

3RD READWALD JETBLACK


Well, what can I say about this girl, I thought she was my class winner for sure. All the right curves. Lovely coat, good length and range but she would not move without pacing, a habit she needs to break. I gave her several chances but could not give her a higher placing as I was unable to assess her movement.

 
4TH WICKWARR WAGG  
5TH COOKLANDS DIBBS  
CLASS 1946 SPECIAL JUNIOR BITCH - 5 ENTRIES 1 ABSENT

1ST KILLOETER LURAG FOR HAMILTONHILL


This is a big rangy bitch who won her place on movement. Excellent front with good forechest and adequate depth for her age, nice length in the body and kept a good profile on the move. She has a lot of time to mature and I saw in her something special for the future she just needs time.

2ND WOLFSCASTLE FIDELA


Slightly smaller but oh so shapely, good lay of shoulder and length with a nice rise over the loin and good length from hip to hock which were well let down. Unfortunaterly she also paced but this hound is well constructed and should finish well. Owner and hound need to practice.

3RD CANERIKIE CRANBERRY COOLER

A longer cast hound who did not show herself at all well, she was un co-operative and movement was erratic.

sorry no image
4TH TARTRAVEN KAYHOLM AT REIVERSREACH  
CLASS 1947 YEARLING BITCH 7 ENTRIES 3 ABSENT
1ST KILLOETER LURAG FOR HAMILTONHILL  
2ND WOLFSCASTLE FIDELA  

3RD GLEWLWYD LIANA


Another hound who today did not show all that well and lost her place on movement. Nice type, good head and body, a tad narrow in front Her topline flattens on the move, but she has good hind antulation and a lovely coat.

4TH HYNDSIGHT ON APPEAL  
CLASS 1948 POST GRADUATE BITCH - 14 ENTRIES 3 ABSENT

1ST HYDFRON BERKITA


A very pretty shapely bitch with lovely front and hind angulation, nice length in her body and a correct topline, she has the sort of head I love and moved with drive covering the ground well. Good lay of shoulder with forechest, nice strong bone and standing and moving she kept her curves.

2ND CANISHURN ZENA


I really thought this would be my winner, a different type to one and going over her I was not disappointed but she failed her owner on the move. Lovely type with a excellent dark coat. Beautiful head and nice small ears excellent body shape with lovely strong hind quarters.

3RD CLAONAIGLEN ORRIN


Bad luck to meet one and two, this is another very nice bitch with much of the qualities of the second place winner.

4TH COTSWOLD CROCUS OF PENHERALD  
5TH DRAWING DOWN THE MOON TO CUSIDH  
CLASS 1949 LIMIT BITCH 10 ENTIRES 4 ABSENT

1ST CLAONAIGLEN ALBYN AT CLOWESWOOD


This was my star, not overdone, no exaggerations, lovely head ears and strong neck, deep chest with a good forechest and a super shape over the back falling into strong well muscled and angulated quarters. All curves, she did not move with her head too high and radiated health and good order. This is a dog show and she was turned out looking the part, she fitted the standard well and made me smile. She was handled extremely well. Her 1st CC but hopefully not her last .

2ND GREYFLAX A KIND OF MAGIC JW


A much bigger and a different type but she is young and fit and ready for the big time. A more workmanlike hound, and not my type but she fitted the standard well with strong angulation and very powerful body. Moved and worked well with her handler.

3RD BEARDSWOOD MORWENNA


A smaller bitch with some nice proportions, not quite the front of 1 and two but many of the qualities apply. Three very nice bitches that could change places at anytime.

4th GENTOM LIATH CAILEAG OF MARANDIKE  
5th PENDRETHAN MORVAH  
CLASS 1950 OPEN BITCH - 8 ENTRIES 1 ABSENT

1ST CH.GREYFLAX GUINEVERE


I have seen this bitch before and she has improved since she took top honours in 2005. She has matured out into a very respectable hound. Quite balanced with a slightly narrow head and front but she moved extremely well in profile which gave her this class.

2ND GHYLLADARE KINGLAS OF GLENMORLICH


Another big honest bitch with many of the qualities of one, size and substance, nice body, topline and angles from and rear - not overdone.

3RD CH.HYNDSIGHT AU FAIT


I love this bitch, a good front and depth, lovely shapely body with good angles front and rear she has many qualities which I admire but today she seemed very sluggish and had to give way to the younger hounds.

4th GREYFLAX WATERLOO SUNSET  
5TH NL/D/PL/CUTE CONEY O'COCKKAIGNE  
CLASS 1051 GOOD CITIZEN DOG SCHEME (BITCH) 2 ENTRIES
1ST KILLOETER LURAG FOR HAMILTONHILL  
2ND GHYLLADARE KINGLAS OF GLENMORLICH
 
BOB. BOS BP PICTURES

BEST PUPPY

DOG CC - RESERVE DOG CC

BITCH CC BOB - DOG CC BOS

RESERVE BITCH CC

I couldnt resist adding a few casual pictures of my family who came to support me, it was much appreciated.
KAT MIKES LADY , SON PETER, DAUGHTER IN LAW AMANDA, BABY CHRISTINA AND SON MIKE
MY NEW GRANDAUGHTER CHRISTINA